Showing posts with label ASSIGNMENT 1 Contrasts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ASSIGNMENT 1 Contrasts. Show all posts

Sunday, 22 April 2012

Assignment 1 Tutor feedback and response


The feedback on Assignment 1 and on my initial efforts in The Art of Photography have just been received from my tutor, and I am pleased with a very positive response to my approach to the exercises, the research around the subjects, the structure and content of the blog and the majority of the images submitted for assessment.  There are a few of the sixteen submitted images that I plan to re-shoot, two just requiring adjustments to the lighting to emphasise the quality of the contrast I was attempting to display with the subjects I chose, and one that needs a re-think.
The overall summary was:-

“You made a very good start to your start to your course.   Your photography is up to the expected standard at this stage of the course and you have dealt with this assignment very well. 
Your log is comprehensive and complete and impresses me with the full treatment you are giving your exercises because this is an important component in your learning experience.
My examination of your images and the other contents of your blog indicate that you have taken one of the most important steps to successfully completing this course which is to allocate sufficient time to general study, working on the exercises and consideration of the requirements of the assignments”.
Response to the contrast ‘straight’ was that the “ image interprets the contrast very well but I would draw your attention to the rather bald sky in which there is almost no tone at all”.  I totally agree with this and I’ve looked back at the image in Lightroom but there is nothing in the way of tone that can be extracted from the sky in the image as shot, but I will certainly be more aware of this in the future.
My tutor’s view of the ‘soft’ image was that “The success of the image of a powdered substance rests in its generally accepted reputation for softness.   Your image of the feathers could have succeeded if the colours were softer, say white and floating in the air rather than at rest.   Your image is dark and rather inexplicit for the task”.  I wondered about this at the time as I did not use the sweet/orange and sour/lemon images for my final submission because it relied entirely on the viewer knowing that oranges were sweet and lemons were sour and this could not be informed by the image alone.  I should have wondered some more and not used the powders maybe ..  The image is indeed dark and has been lightened as below. 

However, a little later I gave further consideration to this and decided to drop the powders for 'soft' and to shoot an image that was aligned with the ball theme I had used for 'hard'.  To this end I produced the following:



Interesting that the tutor comment mentioned the feather, because as it happens, my original efforts at ‘soft’ did involve dropping the feathers down in front of a white backdrop and photographing them as they fell, but I failed to get an image I was satisfied with.  However, I do plan to come back to this in the future.
The tutor view of ‘hard’ was that “In my opinion the cricket ball does look harder by virtue of its glossy surface.   If you restricted your choice to the salt crystals alone and lit it to pick up their reflective nature it could have succeeded better”.  The cricket ball does indeed look hard, especially as the light was catching the gloss of the wax, so this would have been a better option to offer as ‘hard’.  I have added this image to the portfolio to represent this contrast for my final submission..

The rough surface of the tree bark was seen as successful, but the wooden fish not so.   “The surface grain pattern on the fish is unsuccessful in giving the impression of smoothness (Although it may well feel smooth to the touch).  The strong surface pattern disguises its true qualities.  If you positioned your subject in relation to the light source to create a shine on its surface it could have achieved the effect you were looking for”.  I took some more pictures of the fish with the lighting specifically set to show the smoothness of the surface.  I did this by ensuring that the natural daylight was from the front of the fish and used a shallower depth of field (f/6.7) to throw the tail out of focus and emphasise the head where the shiny smoothness was apparent.  I also took more time to set up the shot and photographed it in such a way that it was nicely set up with a  white foamcore board some way behind to give a diffuse and featureless background to emphasise the fish.

My version of ‘high’ was the 310m high ‘Shard’ in London – can’t get much higher than that – and it was seen as a successful image.  ‘Low’ was a failure with the comment being  “I am afraid that the point of this image escapes me.   You took your first image from the ground; looking up to get the effect of height and a suitable contrast could have been obtained from a high viewpoint looking down using the perspective to give the impression of height.  Please do not take any unnecessary risks”.  I agree absolutely that ‘low’ missed the point and was an image that offered nothing.  I wanted to stay with the architectural theme and looked through some of the images I took at the London Eye where everything on the ground looks low!  My selection as a replacement image was an image of Westminster from the top of the Eye.

Added January 2013

I have spent nearly a year looking for an image to try and replicate the view of the Shard, except looking down instead of up.  I think I finally got close and will be replacing the above image with the following as my submission 'low'.  Shot at a very high ISO of 3200 and even then only getting 1/20sec shutter speed on a moving escalator, I managed to get some of the shapes of the Shard reflected in this image.



Now back to my original feedback response ....

Other image pairs not specifically mentioned were seen as successful from the perspective of Assignment 1.
My ‘high/low’ contrast pair was not very successful with the ‘low’.  I obviously need to work on my ‘lows’ or just find another contrast pair!!!  I will consider this over the next few days and submit a further image.

After some thought about what I was really trying to show here, I went for one of the images taken from the top of the London Eye which showed an empty capsule and some of the superstructure taken from the very top of the Eye (high!), and London down below (low!).

Monday, 9 April 2012

PART 1 : Final thoughts


Well, I’ve completed the exercises and non-assessed Assignment 1 in about 10 weeks, which in view of limited time and the length of some of the exercises themselves, I am very pleased with, especially as the first time round it inevitably takes time to set up the blog and establish a way of working to complete the exercises and consider what has been learnt from each. 

More pleasing in many ways is the amount of background reading I have completed (see the references list in the blog side bar) and the influence and inspiration I have gained from the events I have attended.  I am genuinely surprised at how much of a difference I have seen in my own photography and how I approach taking a picture, even with the subject types with which I am most familiar.  Additionally, I have found that I now take a much more considered approach to reading photographs and thinking about the relationship between their individual elements and also to how my eye moves around an image and how I feel about what I see.

Blogging has been a great way of recording progress through the course, although the vagaries of Blogger are irritating in the extreme.  I write everything in Word using Ariel 11 font before uploading, and Blogger’s habit of changing font size, adding in extra line spaces occasionally obliterating paragraphs which were clearly present is bloody annoying.  The hard copy Learning Journal has been a success and has enabled me to capture prints of some of the images I was not able to reproduce in the blog other than by linking to originals.  I have treated it as more of a scrap book and it has been good to be able to revisit pages and scribble in notes as thoughts have occurred to me.  My tutor has stated that he does not need this to be submitted for the first non-assessed assignment, but I will be sending it along on subsequent occasions as I believe that it adds significantly to the blog and has always been produced with the intention of the two being followed side by side.

The visit to the Taylor-Wessing portrait competition was a real eye opener - the first non-wildlife photography exhibition I have attended – and it was fascinating to see the differences between the highly contrived studio or location portraiture and the ad hoc images which were taken as a situation was found.  The latter category made more impact on me initially as it seemed more real, but upon a month’s reflection, I will confess to a growing interest in understanding and actually doing some studio based portrait photography myself.  To this end I have signed up to do a two day studio workshop run by the Royal Photographic Society, which I am sure will be of major benefit later in the OCA course.  This is run at Lacock in Wiltshire, conveniently close to the Fox Talbot Museum for a little inspiration.

The New Documentary Forms exhibition at the Tate Modern also made me think more widely about my own photography and especially in producing images that lead the eye around complex scenes – my own work is often of single discrete subjects, as is much wildlife imagery, and I have promised myself that I will make a serious effort throughout the course to consider options to have more content in images where there is potential to do that ….. which of course means thinking about how I want the eye to travel round the image and the message I want to convey.

Michael Freeman (2007) in The Photographer’s Eye covers many of the things I need to consider to make greater impact in my own photography, and his points around composition especially hit home and will be remembered in the future.  The other book which made particular sense was Chris Gomersall’s (2012) Wildlife Photographer – a Course in Creative Photography, especially his focus on taking images that are either narrative and create a sense of place, or abstract close ups to really generate interest in the viewer.  I have attended a number of the author’s workshops and will be doing so again in April by attending his Birds of the North Norfolk photo tour.  In addition to concentrating on portraits of the birds, I will be making a special effort to look more widely around the habitats and see what creativity I can come up with and how much better I can use the available light than I have done in the past.

Starting the OCA course has also widened the range of periodical photographic literature I have reviewed with the monthly Black and White Photography making me think far outside what I have done before, and I have experimented with some of my existing images to produce mono conversions in Lightroom 4.  I have processed several of my Contrasts assignment images in mono, and they were amongst my favourites of those I submitted.  I have downloaded a trial version of Nik software’s Silver EfexPro to check out as well, although I don’t plan to get too far into that at this stage other than to develop a general idea of how it compares with Lightroom 4 black and white conversions (far better by many accounts, but we’ll see).

As far as the OCA is concerned I have been a reasonably regular contributor to the student forums and have also signed up to attend the first ever weekend photography students conference in Leeds in September where it will be good to meet some of the tutors and other students from the course.  This is largely aimed at those further along the road to BA and beyond Level 1, but it will be a valuable insight into what is coming in the future.

So, all in all, a lot has happened since the Big Red Folder fell through the letterbox at the end of January.  A couple of thousand images I would never have taken before have been taken, books that would never have been read have been read, photographers I have never heard of have been studied, and there has been a total change in thought process and approach. Can’t be bad …… onward to Elements of Design!! 
I plan to complete Elements of Design by June 30th 2012.

Sunday, 8 April 2012

Assignment 1 : Contrasts


Final selected images are shown on my flickrPro site at Assignment 1 Images

Go to Actions\View all sizes\Original for full sized images

From the outset I decided not to rush the first Contrasts assignment and to use it as an opportunity to look at some different types of photography as well as producing images for the course.  Potentially, just producing images that addressed the assignment brief could be relatively rapid, but I wanted to avoid doing that and attempt a more considered approach.  I am doing the course for pleasure and have no specific need to proceed at any set pace, and I also want to enjoy it and go off on whatever tangents seem befitting at the time!

The origins of this exercise lie with the Bauhaus School in Dessau, Germany, which was in operation between 1919 and 1933 and which sought to combine the fine arts with crafts and architecture in a holistic approach to design.  The concept was to bring all these skills together in an overall work of art and its participants were encouraged to develop in all areas of art and design using what today we would probably call a multi-media approach; this eventually evolved into Modernist architecture and modern design.  During the formative years of the Bauhaus movement, one Johannes Itten was involved in delivering what was considered to be a highly innovative ‘preliminary course’ to teach the basic knowledge of colour, design, composition and materials.  One of Itten’s student exercises required them to work with ‘Contrasts’ and investigate his contention that composition was indeed founded in contrasts, and although Itten set these as art projects, there is a clear parallel with that which can be achieved in the photographic medium.  In his review of the works of Itten, Freeman (2007) quoted him as asking students to “awaken a vital feeling for the subject through a personal observation” and in the exercises to “experience them with their senses, objectivise them intellectually, and realise them synthetically”

I’m not sure whether I “objectvised them intellectually” or not (sounds like hard work for a scientist!), but I selected nine contrasting pairs from the list in the course notes and therefore had some options from which to select a final submission of eight pairs.  I wanted to use different types of image for this assignment and therefore ruled nothing out in my initial thoughts.  Outdoor, indoor, natural light, artificial light, found or posed situations were all considered as options.  My tutor had no objection to my working with macro for some elements of this task, so I included consideration of that as well.  I also wanted to have another theme running through this in that I wanted to have each one of the pairs linked in some way other than just by visual ‘quality’ – I was really pleased at how this worked out.

A number of the pairs I considered were taken indoors using natural window light.  Lighting crops up later in the course as a major topic, so I didn’t worry too much about my ‘families of angles’ for this assignment as I didn’t want to get diverted from the major purpose of ‘Contrasts’.  I have been preparing for greater use of ‘proper’ photographic lighting by reading Arena (2012) on the Canon Speedlites and Hunter (2006) on setting up studio lighting.

The basic theory behind Itten’s Contrast assignment is to photograph pairs of images that contrast the visual qualities as shown below:
large/small       many/few        transparent/opaque     broad/narrow   diagonal/rounded
continuous/intermittent            long/short        pointed/blunt    liquid/solid       light/dark
hard/soft          thick/thin          smooth/rough              strong/weak                much/little
light/heavy       black/white      still/moving                  high/low           straight/curved
sweet/sour
As a precursor to Assigmnent 1 it was required that 4 pairs of images from existing photographs were selected to represent contrasting pairs.  From the exercise which looked at the influence of shutter speed on subject movement I selected a pair of images taken at 1/350sec and 1/6sec to represent ‘still' and  ‘moving'.
Existing image - 'moving'

Existing image - 'still'
My next pair came from the exercise which looked at the influence of focal length on the resultant image.  Both photographs are of the 16th century bridge over the River Blackwater that I used to exemplify that exercise and show the contrasts of ‘large’ for the close up (taken at 200mm)  and ‘small’ for the distant shot (taken at 24mm).
Existing image - 'large'
Existing image - 'small'

Next comes City Hall in London as a ‘curved’ example and the Millennium Bridge looking towards St Paul’s Cathedral as the ‘straight’ contrast.
Existing image - 'curved'
Existing image- 'straight'
Finally, I used another pair of images from London to show ‘large’ – the dinosaur inside the massive entrance hall of the Natural History Museum (so lots of large ...)  – and ‘small’ represented by a close up of the museum roof showing paintings of small flowers.  These can be seen in the roof at the top of the ‘large’ image and can be photographed from the balcony.
Finally, I used another pair of images to show ‘large’ – the entrance archway of the Natural History Museum – and ‘small’ represented by a small ornate arch at South Hill Park in Berkshire.  These were a contrast pair that I had considered for the main Assignment 1 work, but in the end I simply preferred others that had been intentionally shot as contrasting pairs.
Existing image - 'large'
Existing image - 'small'

I was surprised how easy it was to spot contrasts in pictures, even with the limited amount of ‘stock’ that I have photographed for the course so far.  Once I had ‘got my eye in’ it was relatively easy to see contrasts all over the place even without cropping images to pull out suitable elements to represent various contrasts.
So, to the images for the main part of Assignment 1.  My first images explored the contrast of straight and curved.  I considered a number of options including elements of large bridges (Millennium Bridge and Hungerford Bridge over the Thames in London), some simple wooden structures around a local nature reserve and some hand tools.  The tools I rejected almost immediately as they were difficult to light and visually less pleasing in a photograph than they were in real life (bad lighting and composition on my part most probably, but I failed to produce an image I really liked).   The bridges I finally settled on for possible inclusion were as follows, and I also considered some of these wooden structures in black and white.




A soon as I saw the curved wooden bridge in black and white it brought to mind an image of a wooden fishing platform on a frozen lake that I had taken and had already converted as I felt that colour rather detracted from the scene that already had quite dull and misty light.  I converted a couple of pictures of the bridge and spent some while thinking about which to select.  The one I finally picked was chosen because I liked the diagonal in the composition and because that diagonal complemented that in the fishing platform.  So, my first pair were ‘curved and straight’ and were :
Assignment image 1 - 'curved'
Assignment image 2 - 'straight'

The next pair of images took me rather less time to settle on and photograph. I knew I wanted to do something with ‘soft’ and ‘hard’ and was initially looking for something that was traditionally ‘hard’ – which is what lead to some cricket ball photography, which turned out to be just red and dull!  I looked at some feathers as representative of ‘soft’; these were more successful but as they were a brilliant range of colours I decided in the end to keep them for the colour elements of the course.  Powders are 'soft', and as I wanted to include some close up images, I experimented with ground spices (nice colours too).  This naturally lead on to sea salt crystals and dried peppercorns to give me the ‘hard’ contrast;  I say naturally, but it was only a short step to finding these once I had started to demolish the pantry in search of spices!  I selected the spices and pepper/salt combo as my pair of contrasts as not only did they have the contrast in visual qualities, they also had the obvious connection in that they were related foodstuffs.


Assignment image 3 - 'soft'
Assignment image 4 - 'hard'

My third pair was ‘transparent’ and ‘opaque’ and I hit upon the idea of using the relevant page from the course materials as a backdrop and utilising some real leaves that had been ‘cleared’ in alcohol (i.e. the chlorophyll had been removed so all that remained was the physical structure of the leaf veins) and then dyed, as ‘transparent’.  The obvious choice as the opposite contrast was an uncleared leaf as ‘opaque’.
Assignment image 5 - 'transparent'
Assignment image 6 - 'opaque'

I have the transparent leaves in a number of colours and I am sure that these will feature at some stage later in the course.

I will guarantee that many students have used my fourth choice as subject material with which to illustrate ‘sweet’ and ‘sour’, and it is of course fruit – rather obvious, but also rather colourful.  An orange and an apple, cut in half to show the sweet insides, contrast well with a sour lemon and a lime.  However, I do acknowledge that it is a prerequisite that the viewer is aware of the flavours and what the fruits are.  For this reason I decided later to come back to this and consider one of my alternatives for final submission.


Natural materials again for number five, this time contrasts made from wood.  The bark of a tree, strongly side lit when I took the photograph,  made a great ‘rough’ surface and I spent some time looking for the ‘smooth’ contrast that gave the secondary link I wanted other than just being ‘smooth’.  I finally settled on a wooden fish from Africa which was very smooth in texture – the markings on the fish in some ways also replicated the structure of the bark in the ‘rough’ image.
Assignment image 7 - 'rough'
Assignment image 8 - 'smooth'

Rounded and diagonal was the next contrast I looked at and I had the images I took at the London Eye in mind for this right from the outset.  It is obviously a good candidate for ‘rounded’ and also containing a wealth of opportunities to find diagonals in the structure of the Eye and its supporting steelwork.  I looked at a few of options for ‘rounded’, considering vertical and horizontal framing as well as showing the whole of the Eye and just a ‘rounded’ part of it.  This turned out to be a difficult choice, but having changed my mind several times I decided on the close up partial shot of the Eye as ‘rounded’ (if the theme had been just ‘round’ I would have gone with the shot of the whole structure) to pair up with the vertical of the ‘diagonal’ steelwork taken from inside one of the capsules.  I went with the vertically framed diagonals for the final submission as I thought the symmetry in this shot really added impact.
Assignment image 9 - 'rounded'
If it had been 'round' and not 'rounded' ..
A contender for 'diagonal'
Assignment image 10 - 'diagonal'
My eighth pair of images was ‘high’ and ‘low’, selecting one image from my visits to London and one local image as a contrast.  The London shot was the London Bridge Quarter, also known as The Shard.  It is hard to think of a better example of ‘tall’ without taking pictures of people (which I’m saving for later assignments!) as it will be the tallest building in Western Europe, standing at 310m upon completion.  I could think of no better contrast to The Shard than the lowest building I could think of .. a shed down the lane from where I live!  I do like the peeling paint and the contrasts in the brickwork here, so was pleased to be able to fit it in to the final selection for ‘low’.

Assignment image 11 - 'high'
Assignment image 12 - 'low'

A further contrast I looked at was the concept of ‘light’ and ‘dark’.  For this pair of images I drew on some pictures I took during a brief spell of snowy weather.  The subject was a pine tree that has a certain stark quality to it as it is isolated in the middle of a field.  My image for ‘dark’ was taken shooting into the light with a 3 stop ND filter just as a snow storm was approaching, and the image for ‘light’ was taken in a cold and flat dawn light.  I really liked the contrast between these two images and, very rarely for me, have had these printed up.
Assignment image 13 - 'dark'
Assignment image 14 - 'light'


My oranges, apples, lemons and limes for ‘sweet’ and ‘sour’ have been bothering me for a while, so I reconsidered these in the light of a feeling that they demanded too much knowledge on behalf of the viewer to be considered as a true visual contrast.  I therefore added an additional pair of images to those I was considering for final submission and looked at ‘many’ and ‘few’.  For this I looked at beans .. jelly beans.  ‘Many’ was a shot of a tightly compacted group and ‘few’ just a group of four beans.  These four were spread out which I thought added to the concept of there being few of them looking rather lonely, and were also framed in the top corner of the image as I felt the greater space added to their isolation.  If I’m personalising jelly beans it’s probably time to stop and start the next part of the course!!
Assignment image 15 - 'many'
Assignment image 16 - 'few'

The last topic to be dealt with in Assignment 1 was to combine two visual contrasts into a single shot.  For this I have gone back to London, although I wanted to get away from the London Eye as a source of too many images. Instead, I took some pictures of street scenes along the Embankment heading along towards Tower Bridge. I especially liked this scene here where the ‘high’ flats and bridges I felt provided an interesting contrast with the ‘low’ street scene where the pavement passes beneath.  It would make a good shot for contrasting vertical and horizontal lines as well.
Assignment image 17 - 'high' and 'low'

So that’s the final work for Assignment 1 and ‘Contrasts’ until I get some tutor input. Assembling the images for the ‘contrasts’ was an interesting process that really had me thinking, especially where there were a number of options for consideration.  It also made me think more widely about what I was shooting and set some serious objectives when I went out with the camera.  ‘Contrasts’ was quite a fragmentary exercise in that it was largely possible to photograph anything, and that lack of focus caused me to think harder about exactly what I was attempting to do.  Some of the later assignments seem to have clearer goals, but it will be interesting to see whether I still think that when I get there !!  I will be blogging some overall views on the course tomorrow, but for now, that’s it for Assignment 1.